Guides › Concrete, Amphora & Alternative Wine Vessels
Category Spotlights · 7 min read
Concrete, Amphora & Alternative Wine Vessels
Concrete tanks, amphorae, and other alternative vessels give winemakers something stainless and oak do not: a different texture, a gentle natural temperature buffer, and in some cases controlled micro-oxygenation without the flavour of new oak. They also bring real practical demands — weight, handling, cleaning, and limited temperature control — that shape your cellar planning. This guide explains how the main alternative vessels behave and what to consider before you bring one into your winery.
This is buying education on vessel behaviour, not structural or food-safety engineering advice. Confirm load ratings, lining, and food-contact suitability with the supplier and the relevant specialists for your site.
Why winemakers reach for alternative vessels
Each vessel type changes the wine in characteristic ways. Understanding the "why" makes the "what to check" clearer.
- Concrete has thick walls that buffer temperature swings and a porosity (when unlined) that allows slow, gentle oxygen exchange — a softer, rounder result than inert stainless, without oak flavour. Egg-shaped concrete vessels are also valued for the convection currents their shape encourages, which can keep lees in gentle suspension.
- Amphora and clay (qvevri, tinaja) offer porosity and an ancient, hands-off style of winemaking, often used for skin-contact and low-intervention wines. Behaviour varies widely with the clay and any internal lining.
- Other alternatives include wooden vats (foudres), and stoneware or ceramic vessels, each sitting somewhere between the inertness of stainless and the influence of oak.
How they behave compared with stainless and oak
| Vessel | Oxygen exchange | Temperature behaviour | Flavour influence | Handling demand |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stainless steel | Inert (none) | Needs active control | Neutral | Moderate |
| Oak barrel | Moderate | Buffered by mass | Oak character | Moderate |
| Concrete (unlined) | Low–moderate | Strong natural buffer | Neutral, textural | Very high (weight) |
| Concrete (lined) | Minimal | Strong natural buffer | Neutral | Very high (weight) |
| Amphora / clay | Variable | Buffered | Mostly neutral, textural | High, fragile |
These are general tendencies, not measured values; actual behaviour depends on the specific vessel, lining, and conditions. For a fuller side-by-side, see concrete vs stainless vs oak vessels.
The practical considerations before you buy
The appeal is the texture; the planning is about physics. Work through these before committing.
- Weight and floor loading. Concrete vessels are extremely heavy, full or empty. Confirm the vessel weight and check your floor can carry it; placement may need engineering sign-off.
- Delivery and access. A large concrete egg or amphora may not fit through a standard door or down a cellar ramp. Confirm dimensions and plan the route before ordering — some vessels are placed before walls go up.
- Lining and porosity. Concrete can be unlined (porous) or lined (sealed, e.g. with a coating). Lining changes oxygen behaviour and cleaning, and affects food-contact suitability. Confirm what the vessel is lined with and whether it suits wine contact.
- Temperature control. Many alternative vessels rely on their mass to buffer temperature and have limited or no active cooling. If you need precise fermentation control, ask whether the vessel can take a cooling jacket, plate, or thermowell — and review winery temperature control.
- Cleaning. Porous and irregular surfaces are harder to clean and sanitise than smooth stainless. Confirm the recommended cleaning approach and how the surface holds up to it.
- Fragility and repair. Clay amphorae can crack; concrete can chip or develop faults. Ask about durability, repairability, and what happens if a vessel fails mid-vintage.
- Emptying and movement. Heavy vessels are usually fixed in place. Confirm outlet placement, racking access, and whether you can clean and empty without moving the vessel.
Fitting alternative vessels into the cellar
A few practical patterns from how wineries actually use these vessels:
- Treat them as semi-permanent. Because of weight and access, alternative vessels often stay put for years. Plan their location around drainage, access, and your transfer paths rather than expecting to move them.
- Use them for a portion of a blend. Many wineries ferment or age only part of a lot in concrete or amphora, then blend with stainless or oak lots to dial in texture. This reduces risk while you learn how the vessel behaves.
- Plan transfer carefully. Gentle movement in and out matters, especially for low-intervention styles. Review wine transfer equipment so racking and emptying do not undo the gentleness you bought the vessel for.
- Mind the temperature-control gap. If your region has hot harvests and your vessel has no active cooling, the natural buffer may not be enough. Have a cooling plan before fermentation, not after.
Choosing a shape and size
Alternative vessels come in shapes that stainless and oak rarely match, and the shape is part of what you are buying.
- The egg. Concrete eggs are prized for the convection their curved interior encourages, which keeps fine lees in gentle suspension without stirring. The trade-off is that the shape is harder to clean and access than a flat-bottom tank.
- Upright cylinders and tulip shapes. Easier to access and clean than an egg, while still offering concrete's thermal buffer.
- Amphorae and qvevri. Often buried or partly buried in the traditional Georgian style, which adds another layer of access and cleaning planning, or stood upright in a frame.
Size matters as much as shape. A small vessel buffers temperature less and is easier to place, while a large one buffers more but multiplies every handling and access problem. Many wineries start with one or two modest vessels to learn the style before committing to a larger investment.
Risk and how to manage it
Alternative vessels carry risks that smooth, inert stainless does not, and a sensible plan accounts for them.
- Cleaning and sanitation risk. Porous and irregular surfaces are harder to sanitise, raising spoilage risk if cleaning is neglected. Follow the supplier's cleaning guidance closely and inspect surfaces regularly.
- Oxygen risk. The gentle oxygen exchange that gives concrete and clay their texture can tip into excessive oxidation if a vessel is not topped up or managed. Treat porous vessels like barrels — they need attention, not set-and-forget.
- Structural and failure risk. A cracked amphora or faulted concrete vessel mid-vintage is a serious problem given the weight and the wine inside. Ask about durability and what support the supplier offers if a vessel fails.
- Learning-curve risk. These vessels behave differently from what most cellars are used to. Starting with a portion of a blend, as noted above, limits the downside while you learn.
Used thoughtfully, alternative vessels add a tool to the cellar that stainless and oak cannot replicate — but they reward planning and attention more than convenience.
FAQ
What is a concrete wine tank used for? Concrete wine tanks are used to ferment and age wine with a softer, rounder texture than inert stainless, without adding oak flavour. Their thick walls buffer temperature, and unlined concrete allows gentle oxygen exchange. Egg-shaped versions also encourage convection that keeps lees in suspension.
Are concrete eggs porous? Unlined concrete is mildly porous, allowing slow oxygen exchange similar in spirit to a large barrel but without oak character. Lined or sealed concrete is effectively inert. Confirm with the supplier whether a specific vessel is lined and how porous it is.
What is amphora winemaking? Amphora winemaking ferments or ages wine in clay vessels, a practice dating back thousands of years. It is often associated with skin-contact and low-intervention wines. The clay's porosity and the vessel shape influence texture; behaviour varies with the clay and any internal lining.
Do alternative vessels need temperature control? Many rely on their mass to buffer temperature rather than active cooling, but in warm climates that may not be enough for controlled fermentation. Ask the supplier whether the vessel can accept a cooling jacket or thermowell, and plan temperature management before harvest.
Bottom line
Concrete, amphora, and other alternative vessels offer texture and a gentle natural buffer that stainless and oak cannot, but they demand careful planning around weight, access, lining, cleaning, and temperature control. Many wineries start by fermenting part of a lot in an alternative vessel and blending. Before you buy, confirm weight, lining, food-contact suitability, and cooling options with the supplier.
Browse equipment on wine.equipment to explore tanks and alternative vessels, and shortlist options before you contact suppliers.